The quiet cost of contracts that roll over

Somewhere in your organisation there is a contract nobody has read since it was signed. It might be for bins, phones, a photocopier or power. It has probably renewed itself at least once, and the price has probably gone up each year. Nobody decided that. It is simply what the contract says happens when nobody does anything.

How a roll-over works

Most service contracts are written by the supplier and offered on a take it or leave it basis. Three clauses do the work, and they are usually pages apart. Here is how they can read when you put them side by side.

This Agreement continues for an Initial Term of 36 months and will automatically renew for further terms of 36 months unless either party gives written notice no less than 90 days before the end of the then-current term. The Supplier may increase the Charges on each anniversary by 5% or CPI, whichever is greater. If the Customer terminates before the end of a term, the Customer must pay 30% of the Charges for the remainder of the term.

Illustrative wording written for this guide. It is not taken from any supplier’s contract.

  • The roll-over. The contract doesn’t end. It restarts, often for the full original term.
  • The notice window. You can only leave if you write in before a date that falls months ahead of the end date. Miss it and you are in for another term.
  • The escalation. The price rises every year by a formula that only moves one way.
  • The exit fee. Leaving early costs enough that most customers stay.

What it adds up to

Take a service that costs $10,000 in its first year, on a three-year term with a 5% yearly increase. If it rolls over twice, this is what the same service costs.

$10,000
$11,576
$13,401
$14,775
Year 1
Signed
Year 4
First roll-over
Year 7
Second roll-over
Year 9

Illustrative example: $10,000 increasing by 5% a year. Your contracts will differ.

By year nine the price is 48% higher than the one you agreed to. Some of that would have happened anyway, because costs do rise. The problem is that the price was never tested. In nine years the market may have changed, new suppliers may have arrived, and your own needs may be half what they were. A contract that rolls over never asks.

Loyalty is rarely rewarded

Many industries price the same way: a sharp deal to win a new customer, and a gradual drift upwards for the ones who stay. The best measured example in Australia is household electricity. The ACCC found that households on the same plan for more than three years pay on average $221 a year more than customers on new plans, and that 37% of customers are paying at or above the regulated safety-net price.

“Loyalty penalties are alive and well in the retail electricity market.”ACCC Commissioner Anna Brakey, December 2025

Those figures are for households, because that is where regulators collect the data. There is no equivalent published figure for churches, camps or schools. But the mechanism is the same for an organisation, and the contracts are usually longer and the sums larger.

Where roll-overs hide

These are the places to look first. Not every contract in these areas rolls over, and many suppliers write fair terms. The point is to know which of yours do.

Waste and recyclingMulti-year terms, yearly price rises, bin rental that continues after you leave.
Printers and copiersLease and service bundled together, long terms, charges per page that rise each year.
Electricity and gasWhen a contract ends you usually move to a higher out-of-contract rate.
Phones and internetPlans that continue month to month at the old price long after better ones are on offer.
Software and subscriptionsAnnual renewals charged to a card, often with more licences than you now use.
Cleaning and hygiene servicesWashroom, sanitary and mat services on rolling terms with yearly increases.
Security and fire monitoringMonitoring and maintenance agreements that renew for the original term.
Equipment leasesLeases that keep billing at the full rate after the equipment is paid off.

What the regulator has found

Australia’s competition regulator, the ACCC, has taken action over these kinds of terms in contracts with small businesses.

Waste, 2018

Visy Recycling, Cleanaway and Suez

After an ACCC investigation, all three changed clauses that had let them raise prices on their own decision and charge customers for leaving early. Two of them had required small business customers to pay 30% of the remaining contract payments if they ended early. ACCC media release

Printers, 2022

Fujifilm Business Innovation

The Federal Court declared 38 terms in 11 types of small business contract unfair and void, including automatic renewal, excessive exit fees and price increases on the supplier’s own decision. Around 34,000 contracts had been entered into or renewed on those standard forms since November 2016. ACCC media release

The law has since been strengthened. From 9 November 2023 it is illegal to propose, use or rely on unfair terms in standard form contracts with consumers and small businesses, and courts can impose penalties. A small business for this purpose has fewer than 100 employees or less than $10 million in annual turnover. Whether your organisation is covered depends on your circumstances, so get advice before relying on it. An automatic renewal clause is not unfair in itself. It depends on the whole contract.

Take back the decision

You don’t need to cancel anything to fix this. You need to make sure that each renewal is a decision someone makes, and that it is made before the notice window closes.

Start with a contract register. It is one page, and the column that matters most is the last date you can give notice, not the end date.

Supplier and serviceEnd dateLast day to give noticeYearly increaseWho decides
Example: waste collection30 June 20271 April 20275% or CPIBusiness manager
Example: copier lease14 Sept 202716 June 2027None statedOffice manager

Then, for each contract, put a reminder in the calendar a month before the notice date. When it comes up, ask the supplier for their current price for a new customer, and compare it with what you pay. Before you sign anything new, ask for a shorter term, a renewal that goes month to month, and a cap on the yearly increase. Many suppliers will agree if they are asked.

How OneBuy helps. OneBuy negotiates terms with suppliers on behalf of the whole network, so members aren’t each negotiating alone. If you find a contract coming up for renewal, Ask OneBuy can point you to OneBuy suppliers in that category to compare against.

Sources (checked 16 November 2026)

General information only, not legal or financial advice. Prepared with AI assistance and reviewed by the OneBuy team.

Scroll to Top